1. Welcome to Game Dog Forum

    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

    Dismiss Notice

Mayday vs. Chinaman

Discussion in 'Dog Discussion' started by lrae3, Nov 20, 2011.

  1. slim12

    slim12 Super Moderator Staff Member

    explain what frisco had to do with the ROM status of Chinaman....??????
    either would work for me....the easiest way to prove a dog is not bred the way he is papered is for him to notch five or six wins, and then produce several champions and a bunch of winners....then for whatever reason he/she is never bred as papered..always amazed at this....give me either of these two and then tell me they are off Lassie and Benji with an out of Rin Tin Tin....and i would say set a date and a weight and we can 'discuss' their heritage...if i were into that kind of stuff....US1





     
    Carolinacur likes this.
  2. Dream Pits

    Dream Pits CH Dog

    Yeah not sure why people keep bringing up Frisco, this thread is NOT about Frisco. And Frisco was NOT Chinamans claim to fame, he earned that all on his own.
     
  3. garth

    garth Big Dog

    Chinaman because I prefer dogs of his size and his breeding.I prefer dogs down from China Tom than Frisco I know Tom proved him self,Frisco I don't know.
     
  4. art

    art Big Dog

    mayday he's a grch pluse just game'er
     
  5. benson

    benson Pup

    my perfect bulldog wold be chinaman in a mayday size dog ie a big chinaman
     
  6. skratchr81

    skratchr81 Big Dog

    chinaman. thats a no brainer for me
     
  7. Mayday by far. That is my opinion. Not a Garner bash but that is what I like.
     
  8. babedulce

    babedulce Big Dog

    Exactly, Frisco has absolutely nothing to do with Chinaman's ROM status or his achievements, but somehow Chinaman is always guilty by association.
     
    david63 likes this.
  9. JamesT

    JamesT Top Dog

    I'll take chinaman,yall can keep them ban dogs.lol j/k
     
    david63 likes this.
  10. MiRaGe

    MiRaGe Big Dog

    Starting late has no reflection on the dog being good or not and did not reflect on his offspring
     
    david63 likes this.
  11. redrumdog

    redrumdog Top Dog

    That would be a beast to handle.
     
  12. maydaymatt

    maydaymatt Big Dog

    mine would be mayday of course, but 2 diff caliber dogs. what is it that you are asking in action, producer, what exactly are we choosing?
     
  13. lil mayhem

    lil mayhem Top Dog

    if we're talking versus each other like in other threads I'm still going with Mayday too big too strong and he didn't have quit in him. Think it would have been great match though.
     
  14. Anybody know anything about the medlins outlaw
     
  15. ELIAS'PISTOLA

    ELIAS'PISTOLA CH Dog

    Get the best of both worlds and cross the two...
    When Wildside aquired Hollingsworths dogs and crossed them to thier Eli stock, they had good results...
    And then Garner aquired them from Wildside and crossed them with his Chinaman stock with great results, whether you wanted it or not, TG knew thw neccesisity
    of such a cross...
    Maydays half Hollingsworth and half yellow redboy, graner also aquired redboy dogs to cross to his eli dogs. hmm... If its what TG does it must be gooooooddd...
    Why not cross chinaman/eli with the hollingsworth and redboy lines???
    In most cases, those lines pure in this day are lacking balance, imo...
     
  16. siccen

    siccen Big Dog

    Chinaman is one of the dogs I've been most intrigued by, but so is Mayday. I would definitely go with Chinaman though. Chinaman for me is like when you see that rare footage of the Tasmanian Tiger. You see it, and you just wish you could have been there first hand.
     
    david63 likes this.
  17. Rolldog

    Rolldog Pup

    Chinaman! (NOT! Frisco)
     
    david63 likes this.
  18. ChinaMan for sure!
     
    david63 likes this.
  19. Box Bulldog

    Box Bulldog Top Dog

    Big size difference around 13-14lbs
     
    david63 and Gilberto S like this.
  20. ^^^^^^^^^^^^
    I was thinking the same thing..
    cant give that much away lol.
     
    david63 likes this.

Share This Page