Click here
  1. Welcome to Game Dog Forum

    You are currently viewing our forum as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact us.

    Dismiss Notice

Good small dog beats good big dog 9/10 times

Discussion in 'Dog Discussion' started by BulldogsOfBoudreaux, Jan 22, 2022.

  1. A Great small dog beats a Great big dog, 9/10 times.

    University studies done on dogs and research has confirmed that smaller dogs have

    1. faster reaction times

    2. greater ability to accelerate body movements

    3. stronger muscles in proportion to body weight

    4. greater endurance and the ability to rotate the body faster

    5. less likelihood of breaking bones when falling

    6. superior cardiovascular endurance

    7. healthier blood flow, less inflammation

    Bigger dogs carry more weight which can even out in the box. Smaller dogs are more stable on the ground and they tend to be faster and more explosive.

    Smaller dogs are more flexible, and less prone to injury than big dogs are during fighting. They are more durable.

    It takes less time for sensory information to travel to a small dogs brain, thanks to a process called “temporal binding”. The brain receives sensory data from different parts of the body at different speeds, so it synchronizes conflicting messages by defaulting to the slowest processing speed. Which means, for a bigger dog, a touch on his toe will take longer to travel to his brain, as will other sensory messages.
     
    Box Bulldog likes this.
  2. ben brockton

    ben brockton CH Dog

    This is complete bullshit. Being in all your a fan of Floyd then ask him what a difference 3 pounds made against bullyson. Then ask him if he would give up 5 lol
     
  3. According to you, research based facts is bullshit.

    Mr. Boudreaux is the one who told me a great small bulldog beats a great big bulldog. Thank you very much.
     
  4. Box Bulldog

    Box Bulldog Premium Member Premium Member


    I agree with this. Its the same with people. Look at boxers for example. There are not to many Heavyweights that have the athletic ability of a lightweight, speed,reflexes,movement,coordination,endurance there is no comparison. And with the dogs take a little jack russell they can run damn close to 30mph, jump 5' in the air, turn on a dime and so on find a dog of any breed 100lbs plus that is comparable pound for pound. They don't exist. I use to do a fair bit of dog weight pull and the smaller dogs of various breeds out pull the amount of times their body weight than larger dogs and breeds.
     
    david63 likes this.
  5. Box Bulldog

    Box Bulldog Premium Member Premium Member

    You got the saying wrong. A ''great'' smaller dog beats a ''good'' bigger dog. That's what it is suppose to say. With two greats the bigger will win.
     
    david63 likes this.
  6. AGK

    AGK Super duper pooper scooper Administrator

    In weight pulling I'd agree. In the game, not at all. Big good dog wins 9/10 times against a good small dog. It's like saying if Mayweather meet Tyson in both their primes Mayweather would win. He'd get knocked the fuck out viciously and violently. Little guy is faster and more agile but big guy only needs to connect once and it's curtains.. 5lbs in the dog world is like 25 on a human. Unless your lil guy is an Ace, it's very unlikely going to prevail. Even if he is an ace after 10lbs it most likely won't matter much unless the big dog is a cur.
    My money would be going on the larger dog.

    Just my 2 cents worth.
    Worth about, 2 cents... lol.
     
  7. slim12

    slim12 Super Moderator Staff Member

    In weight pull, yes. As the pound for pound performance can sometimes not even be close.

    In a box situation a small dog only prevails if the big dog is a cur. If the big dog stays the size will eventually win out. Thus the golden rule of never give weight regardless of what you think of your animal.

    The same 'principle' works in reverse as well. Giving two pounds to a 50lb dog is one thing but giving 2 pounds to a 35lb dog is totally different. 2 pounds is not 2 pounds all the time.

    The research is probably accurate in every other venue but there has never been research of that kind done with actual box time as proof.

    Sometimes research on other breeds/other efforts is transferrable to the bulldog game but the kicker will always be there is no actual research in the the bulldog game, not like that anyway.

    S
     
    oldguy and Box Bulldog like this.
  8. GK1

    GK1 Big Dog

    LOL..define "small dog" and "large dog". OP points 1-7 are conjecture, nothing more.
     
    tomjones2 and chili like this.
  9. ben brockton

    ben brockton CH Dog

    Theoretically speaking give me 5lb and in return I give you back a dead dog lmfao
     
    david63, bollybok, oldguy and 2 others like this.
  10. Dusty Road

    Dusty Road CH Dog

    the reason they have a top weight , if both dogs are good , the bigger dog will be a smaller dog 99% of the time
     
    david63, tomjones2 and oldguy like this.
  11. tomjones2

    tomjones2 Big Dog

    Eh?
     
  12. Great small dog defeats great big dog 99.9% of the time
     
  13. CockneyRebel

    CockneyRebel Big Dog

    So why do they have weigh-in's then, what's the point of it all?
     
  14. oldguy

    oldguy CH Dog

    So is it same for boxers & MMA fighters? Does a great lightweight beat a great heavyweight? I think that's nonsense.

    2 champion males I saw.. Scotsman's CH Yogi was 42lb and Hell's Jock's CH. Bash was 38lb
    Bash had bigger reputation in area and Yogi was up and coming, egos & bragging rights won over common sense as usual and Scotsman convinced Bash's (original) owner to give away 4lb to match Yogi at 42lb.. Long story short I still believe Bash was better dog than Yogi, but fact is the weight difference was too much for him and after 1.17 he needed picked up, not that Bash wanted picked up since he was so game that he actually believed her was winning, but he needed out of there for his own good.. Now would Yogi have beat Bash if the weights were even? IMO never!
    Neither of aforementioned dogs were aces, but they was very good dogs.

    Another dog I seen was GR CH Bill, he was considered by everyone who saw him (including Indian Sonny) to be an ace.. Bill could fight anywhere between 55lb - 65lb and was open to any dog calling itself a fighting dog and at 'ANY' weight.
    IMO no dog any weight could beat Bill and anyone willing to give weight away to Bill (regardless of their ace) was only condemning their dog to a quicker death.
     
    david63, tomjones2 and bollybok like this.
  15. Dusty Road

    Dusty Road CH Dog

    you know very little if you believe that
     
    KSL, david63, reids skipper and 4 others like this.
  16. Mashamplan

    Mashamplan Big Dog

    Why are you guys still entertaining this nonsensical statement?
    Maybe if the topic was around your preference for a small great dog or big great dog then it will come down to a personal opinion, that doesnt involve facing the two off against each other in the box.
     
  17. wicked13

    wicked13 CH Dog

    There's There's story somewhere of a small champion getting killed by a bigger dog only to quit from a dog it's own size ..in a short time also
     
  18. Mr.Revolution

    Mr.Revolution CH Dog

    Some of the stupidest shit I ever heard.
     
    FrozenEli, Bolushi and chili like this.
  19. Bolushi

    Bolushi Banned

    Hell we don't even know the context. Now if I'm not delusional, which I may be, I think a 30lb Amstaff would in fact lose to a 120lb Mastiff. I'm not sure, it is smaller so it is better, but just a thought.
     
  20. Bolushi

    Bolushi Banned

    While the smaller size can give all these small perks, they are still dogs and size can make all the difference. I'm not sure all of these are true.
    Endurance may help, not when you can't move though.
    Nobody will be breaking bones from a fall in a fight.
    I'm sure the blood flow would make all the difference, that can be a real game changer!
    I think a good small dog against a good big dog is a 50/50 depending on how drastic of a size difference it is. If it is same breed, and 1 dog is giving up 3lbs, you're stupid to think the dog giving away weight has a good shot.
    If a dog is outsized by 100lbs and the other dog isn't a complete cur then you are stupid to think the smaller dog would win even a single round.
     

Share This Page