Mayday vs. Chinaman

Neither....

Of course I probably already said that lmao. I have a dose of mayday here but am breeding away from it in my program.

 

Mostly because its easier to match at that weight, good luck finding a match for 70 lb dog.

 

Arguably the best example of an unimpressively aesthetic looking dog being a total beast.

 

It's obvious you don't like CH Chinaman and that's fine.

 

no lmao i quoted the wrong post, i was talking about plumbers gator, who is an awesome dog but also ugly as sin, doesn't lessen his fighting prowess tho.

 

I do not care for Mayday dogs.

 

Alright bud-

 

I will give you that.

 

Likely because most gators pics are at chain weight, he looks much better in the conditioned state.

 

Really? This is a beauty

 

Extremely horrible argument. Prime Muhammad Ali would probably have had a difficult time in a much lower weight class, but it’s an irrelevant fact. Mayday overall is more impressive he’s a household name.

Other things aside, Hypothetically If they were to meet in the square at a catch weight or whatnot , mayday wouldn’t be phased by chinamans extreme intelligence and athleticism. Intelligence is overrated. maydays brute fearlessness and gameness would be way too much. The killing machine would lay the hammer down right on chinaman.

 

Velesoid you say gators aesthetic are not impressive to you and you say he is as ugly as sin. He is amazing to me. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. You cannot define others like that. Here’s some gator

 

It is my opinion that i find him ugly compared to some other lines and to it i am entitled, i never questioned the working ability.

both dogs in question are equally game, chinaman has arguably better stamina and mayday the harder mouth. regardless, mayday has 25 pound weight advantage and would eat chinaman

 

and at Chinamans weight , Mayday might not have strength to stand up

 

Big weight difference. But At maydays weight or a catch weight, chinaman gets bloody murdered.

 

This is like saying "but mike tyson would totally die at maywethers weight"

 

As is this.

This topic is like the age old question " how many licks does it take to get to the center of a tootsie pop".. Lol

 

Speculation leads to nothing.
It's like comparing apples to oranges,
Both were good dogs in their time in a different period on a different weight.
And both are deceased, RIP.

 

Its not really speculation, mayday would beat the tar out of chinaman at normal weights. At same weight you would have severely malnourished and half dead mayday

Its like pitting heavyweight boxer against a lightweight. Not fair but a pretty obvious outcome